Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Butterfinger Surprises

May 23, 2022Teresa

Butterfinger Surprises are so delightful. These Peanut Butter Cookies contain Butterfinger Bits in every bite. So if you enjoy Butterfingers, these cookies are for you! I loved the way these cookies turned out. Because I used a large cookie scoop, they’re mammoth sized and just loaded with flavor.

Follow Me On Instagram!

I made these cookies a couple of months ago for a dessert I took to a potluck at our church for Empty Nesters. I sent some home with some friends who love cookies. These cookies were very well received especially because they’re Peanut Butter Cookies in disguise! Adding the Butterfinger Bits makes them even more delicious.

Since I use a large cookie scoop to make these cookies, they take a little longer to bake. Even still, these are really substantial cookies. They’re whoppers and they’re oh, so good. Seriously, every bite will have you drooling.

If you’re a Butterfinger lover, these cookies will knock your socks off. Why not enjoy peanut butter, chocolate and Butterfingers in every bite? Why not, indeed. 🙂

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Butterfinger Surprises will knock your socks off!

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

These Peanut Butter Cookies are filled with Butterfinger Bits!

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

You’ll be drooling over every bite.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

These whopper-sized cookies almost make up a meal!

Here’s what I did.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

I used these ingredients.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Soften butter. Add granulated sugar, brown sugar, crunchy peanut butter, vanilla and eggs.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Mix with an electric mixer until smooth.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Place UNBLEACHED all-purpose flour in a mixing bowl. (Bleached flour toughens baked goods). Add salt, baking soda and baking powder.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Stir really well to combine.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Add flour mixture and Butterfinger Bits.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Stir very well with a heavy metal spoon, until all the flour has been worked in. This may take a couple of minutes but make sure the mixture is no longer floury.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Scoop out dough with a large cookie scoop. I usually pack it in really well so the ingredients adhere well.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Place cookie dough balls on greased cookie sheets.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Bake cookies at 350 degrees for 12 to 15 minutes or until done. Rotate cookie sheets on racks every 6 minutes during baking time.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Now it’s time to sit down with a glass of milk and enjoy a stack of Butterfinger Surprises. 🙂

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Butterfinger Bits really amp up the flavors of these marvelous cookies.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

We loved the way Butterfinger Surprises turned out. Every mouthful was so satisfying and delicious.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

If you enjoy Butterfingers, you’ll love Butterfinger Surprises.

Here’s the recipe.

BUTTERFINGER SURPRISES

(My own concoction)

Print Recipe
Butterfinger Surprises BigOven - Save recipe or add to grocery list Yum
Butterfinger Surprises are mouthwatering and irresistible. These luscious Peanut Butter Cookies are filled with Butterfinger Bits giving chocolaty, peanut butter and Butterfinger taste in every bite. If you enjoy Butterfinger Bars these cookies should be on your regular baking list. Wow your company or friends by bringing these fantastic cookies to tailgating parties, potlucks, soccer or gym practice or even holiday dinners. Everyone will rush to get a second or third cookie, and you'll probably have to make a second batch.
Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises
Votes: 1
Rating: 5
You:
Rate this recipe!
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 12 to 15 minutes
Servings
Ingredients
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 12 to 15 minutes
Servings
Ingredients
Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises
Votes: 1
Rating: 5
You:
Rate this recipe!
Instructions
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  2. Cream butter, peanut butter, sugars, eggs and vanilla until fluffy.
  3. Stir flour, baking powder, baking soda and salt together; gradually stir dry ingredients into mixture.
  4. Stir in Butterfinger bits until mixture is well mixed and no longer floury.
  5. Scoop cookie dough with a large cookie scoop and place on greased baking sheets.
  6. Bake 12 to 15 minutes or until lightly browned.
  7. Rotate cookies on racks every 6 to 7 minutes of baking time.
Recipe Notes

NOTE: When I was baking two racks at a time, my cookies took 21 minutes to bake. When I baked a single rack (and didn’t need to rotate the cookies), the cookies took about 15 minutes to bake. Smaller cookies won’t take so long to bake.

NOTE: Stir ingredients really well. These are not muffins! The cookie dough needs to be stirred until every morsel is no longer floury-looking.

© Can’t Stay Out of the Kitchen
Nutrition Facts
Butterfinger Surprises
Amount Per Serving
Calories 322 Calories from Fat 144
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 16g 25%
Saturated Fat 7g 35%
Polyunsaturated Fat 1g
Monounsaturated Fat 2g
Cholesterol 32mg 11%
Sodium 154mg 6%
Potassium 43mg 1%
Total Carbohydrates 39g 13%
Dietary Fiber 1g 4%
Sugars 23g
Protein 6g 12%
Vitamin A 5%
Calcium 5%
Iron 2%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.

 

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

I was not stingy with the Butterfinger Bits. There are a lot of them in these luscious Peanut Butter Cookies.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Butterfinger Surprises are monster sized!

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

It’s time to try a bite.

Butterfinger Surprises | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | these luscious #PeanutButterCookies include #ButterfingerBits in every bite. These whopper-sized #cookies will knock your socks off! If you enjoy #PeanutButter #chocolate & #Butterfingers, this #dessert will make your day! #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert #Butterfinger Dessert #holiday #HolidayBaking #HolidayDessert #ButterfingerSurprises

Butterfinger Surprises are perfect for potlucks, tailgating parties, holiday menus or just because.

You may also enjoy these delicious recipes!

Butterfinger Cookies

Butterfinger Cookies | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen

Butterfinger Candy Bar Cookies

Butterfinger Candy Bar Cookies | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen

Butterfinger Chocolate Chip Cookies

Butterfinger Chocolate Chip Cookies | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen

8 Comments

  • woodoku

    June 27, 2022 at 3:29 am

    You must give it a go. It’s not tough at all. Follow the images and instructions provided.

    1. Teresa

      June 27, 2022 at 7:39 am

      Right.

  • 1v1 lol unblocked

    June 21, 2022 at 1:33 am

    Thank you for sharing your passion, I am not good at cooking and this is a great recipe for me

    1. Teresa

      June 21, 2022 at 12:30 pm

      It is a great recipe.

  • Varsity Jackets

    June 7, 2022 at 6:34 am

    I loved your blog post about trying new recipes and sharing your family’s favorite recipes. I’ve always wanted to try to make some of your recipes, but I’m terrified of cooking. I can’t imagine making these cookies for a party though, I think that might be too much for me.

    1. Teresa

      June 7, 2022 at 11:11 am

      You need to give it a try. It’s not that difficult. Follow the pictures and instructions.

  • Stephanie

    May 23, 2022 at 9:58 am

    Waaaait!!! Which Butterfinger cookie of yours do you prefer? They all look like perfection. Are there textural differences?

    1. Teresa

      May 26, 2022 at 7:44 am

      Hi Stephanie. Yes they’re all different. This one has the most body of all of them. It’s also a peanut butter cookie with Butterfingers added, rather than the dough for a chocolate chip cookie with Butterfingers added, if that makes sense. (I like all of them, but this one is one of my favorites).

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.