Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Butterfinger Pie

Teresa Ambra

Butterfinger Pie is one of the best desserts you’ll ever eat. If you’re looking for a fantastic dessert pie for special occasions or holidays like Valentine’s Day, this is it! This rich, luscious pie is filled with Butterfingers. It has all that delicious peanut butter and chocolate taste you love in Butterfinger Bars. But you get to eat it as a pie instead! It’s so outrageously wonderful.

Follow Me On Instagram!

I asked my husband to pick up a LOT of Halloween candy when it went on sale half price. I planned on making all kinds of pies and cookies with them. He picked up a boat load of stuff. It was so much, that I had pies and cookies coming out my ears for weeks on end.

I sent several of these out to John’s office. Then I made a couple more for our Friday night Bible study group and our Sunday night college group. Without doubt, Butterfinger Pie was a big winner. One of the guys in our Friday night group loves Butterfingers as his favorite candy bar. He couldn’t get enough of this pie. I found it was irresistible with ice cream and caramel sauce over top. Ohhhh, yes!!!

Butterfinger Pie isn’t really that difficult to make. Especially if you use a store bought pie crust. It will take five to ten minutes to chop up the candy bars. But that’s the most time intensive part of preparing this pie. I loved the way this pie turned out. It had perfect texture, but my, oh my, it’s rich. Yes, indeed. If you want to knock the socks off your spouse or friends, this is the dessert that will do it. Enjoy.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Butterfinger Pie is outrageously irresistible!

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

It’s terrific with vanilla ice cream and caramel sauce drizzled over top.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Butterfinger Pie is ideal for holidays like Valentine’s Day.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

It’s also great for company dinners and special occasions.

Here’s what I did.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

I used these ingredients.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Roll out pie crust.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Press into pan; flute edges. Set aside.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Beat eggs with an electric mixer until frothy. This will take between 3-5 minutes.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Add UNBLEACHED all-purpose flour. Bleached flour toughens baked goods. Add sugar and brown sugar.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Mix ingredients with an electric mixer until smooth.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Add melted butter.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Mix again with an electric mixer until ingredients are incorporated. Be careful of splatters!

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Add two cups of chopped Butterfingers.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Stir ingredients to combine.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Pour filling into prepared pie shell.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Bake in a preheated 325 degree oven for 45 minutes. Remove pie from oven.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Sprinkle remaining cup of Butterfingers on top of pie.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Return to oven and bake pie an additional 30 minutes or until set.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Serve warm with ice cream, if desired.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Butterfinger Pie is so delicious you’ll be hard pressed to share with others!

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

This pie is extremely rich. It’s perfectly scrumptious just eating it plain.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

I found it over the top with ice cream and caramel sauce drizzled over top.

Here’s the recipe.

BUTTERFINGER PIE

(My own concoction)

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Butterfinger Pie

Teresa Ambra
Butterfinger Pie is one of the best desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with Butterfingers so it's got a delightful peanut butter & chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing pie for Valentine's Day, other holidays or special occasions. No one will be able to stay out of it.
5 from 2 votes
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 1 minute
Total Time 16 minutes
Course Dessert, Pies
Cuisine American
Servings 8
Calories 747 kcal

Equipment

  • 1 9-inch pie plate
  • 1 large mixing bowl
  • 1 electric mixer
  • 1 wooden spoon
  • measuring cups
  • measuring spoons
  • 1 sharp knife to chop Butterfingers

Ingredients
  

  • 2 large eggs
  • 1/2 cup UNBLEACHED all-purpose flour (bleached flour toughens baked goods)
  • 1/2 cup granulated sugar
  • 1/2 cup brown sugar packed
  • 1 cup unsalted butter melted and cooled slightly (2 sticks)
  • 3 cups Butterfinger Candy Bars chopped, divided use
  • 1 unbaked pie shell

Instructions
 

  • Preheat oven to 325°.
  • In large bowl, beat eggs until foamy; this will take 3-5 minutes.
  • Beat in flour, granulated sugar and brown sugar until well-blended.
  • Blend in the cooled, melted butter.
  • Stir in 2 cups chopped Butterfinger candy bars.
  • Pour into pie shell.
  • Bake at 325° for 45 minutes.
  • Sprinkle remaining chopped Butterfinger candy bars on top.
  • Continue baking an additional 30 minutes.
  • Serve warm with whipped cream or ice cream.

Notes

NOTE: I used about 1 ½ 10.2-oz. bags fun-size Butterfinger Bars to equal 3 cups of chopped Butterfingers.
 
© Can’t Stay Out of the Kitchen

Nutrition

Calories: 747kcalCarbohydrates: 90gProtein: 7gFat: 42gSaturated Fat: 23gPolyunsaturated Fat: 4gMonounsaturated Fat: 12gTrans Fat: 1gCholesterol: 108mgSodium: 262mgPotassium: 215mgFiber: 2gSugar: 56gVitamin A: 777IUCalcium: 54mgIron: 2mg
Keyword Butterfingers, chocolate, chocolate dessert, dessert, peanut butter, pie
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!
Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Butterfinger Pie is filled with the flavors of chocolate and peanut butter. It is wondrously spectacular!

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Having a few Butterfingers broken up and served on top of the ice cream was quite fantastic too.

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Are you drooling yet? It’s probably time for a sample. 🙂

Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

You may also enjoy these delicious recipes!

Butterfinger Delight

Butterfinger Delight | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen

Butterfinger Blondies

Butterfinger Blondies | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen

Chocolate Butterfinger Cupcakes

Chocolate Butterfinger Cupcakes | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen
Butterfinger Pie | Can't Stay Out of the Kitchen | This is one of the best #desserts you'll ever eat. It's rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It's filled with #Butterfingers so it's got a delightful #PeanutButter & #chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing #pie for #ValentinesDay, other #holidays or special occasions. #ButterfingerCandy #ButterfingerPie #ChocolateDessert #PeanutButterDessert

Butterfinger Pie

Teresa Ambra
Butterfinger Pie is one of the best desserts you’ll ever eat. It’s rich, decadent & outrageously irresistible. It’s filled with Butterfingers so it’s got a delightful peanut butter & chocolate taste. Wow your family & friends with this amazing pie for Valentine’s Day, other holidays or special occasions. No one will be able to stay out of it.
5 from 2 votes
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 1 minute
Total Time 16 minutes
Course Dessert, Pies
Cuisine American
Servings 8
Calories 747 kcal

Equipment

  • 1 9-inch pie plate
  • 1 large mixing bowl
  • 1 electric mixer
  • 1 wooden spoon
  • measuring cups
  • measuring spoons
  • 1 sharp knife to chop Butterfingers

Ingredients
  

  • 2 large eggs
  • 1/2 cup UNBLEACHED all-purpose flour (bleached flour toughens baked goods)
  • 1/2 cup granulated sugar
  • 1/2 cup brown sugar packed
  • 1 cup unsalted butter melted and cooled slightly (2 sticks)
  • 3 cups Butterfinger Candy Bars chopped, divided use
  • 1 unbaked pie shell

Instructions
 

  • Preheat oven to 325°.
  • In large bowl, beat eggs until foamy; this will take 3-5 minutes.
  • Beat in flour, granulated sugar and brown sugar until well-blended.
  • Blend in the cooled, melted butter.
  • Stir in 2 cups chopped Butterfinger candy bars.
  • Pour into pie shell.
  • Bake at 325° for 45 minutes.
  • Sprinkle remaining chopped Butterfinger candy bars on top.
  • Continue baking an additional 30 minutes.
  • Serve warm with whipped cream or ice cream.

Notes

NOTE: I used about 1 ½ 10.2-oz. bags fun-size Butterfinger Bars to equal 3 cups of chopped Butterfingers.
 
© Can’t Stay Out of the Kitchen

Nutrition

Calories: 747kcalCarbohydrates: 90gProtein: 7gFat: 42gSaturated Fat: 23gPolyunsaturated Fat: 4gMonounsaturated Fat: 12gTrans Fat: 1gCholesterol: 108mgSodium: 262mgPotassium: 215mgFiber: 2gSugar: 56gVitamin A: 777IUCalcium: 54mgIron: 2mg
Keyword Butterfingers, chocolate, chocolate dessert, dessert, peanut butter, pie
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

2 Comments

  • Portia

    January 17, 2020 at 3:50 pm

    Next time I need to bake something this will be it. Sounds amazing. Thank you.
    And thanks for the tip about using unbleached flour. I didn’t know there is a difference.

    1. Teresa

      January 17, 2020 at 4:14 pm

      Thanks, Portia. I hope you enjoy the recipe. It’s really terrific. Especially if you enjoy Butterfinger candy bars. 🙂

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Previous Post Next Post